Skip to content

Caitlin Margaret Nicotra, DO

NPI 1467848143ActiveIndividual· Obstetrics & Gynecology· Buffalo, NY

Obstetrics & Gynecology (DO) in Buffalo, New York, trained at Lake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicine, Erie (class of 2015). Their prescriptions cost Medicare Part D more than their services did: $36,810 for 177 claims, against $2,981 paid for services in 2024. Biogen, Inc. was the largest of 5 companies reporting payments in 2025, $106.57 in all, mostly food and beverage.

Overview

NPI1467848143
StatusActive
Entity typeIndividual
CredentialDO
Sole proprietorNo
NPI issuedApr 9, 2015
Last updated in NPPESMar 28, 2019

Specialties and licenses

TaxonomyCodeLicenseState
Obstetrics & Gynecology Primary207V00000X297398NY

About license numbers in NPPES

Exclusion screening

ListResultDetails
HHS-OIG LEIE · Nov 10, 2026No matchChecked by NPI and by name + state
North Carolina Medicaid · Nov 11, 2026No match—
New York OMIG · Nov 11, 2026No match—
Ohio Medicaid · Nov 11, 2026No match—
Pennsylvania Medicheck · Nov 11, 2026No match—
Washington HCA · Nov 11, 2026No match—

Official OIG search · How matching works ·Bulk check a roster

Medicare

Enrollment (PECOS)Enrolled Practitioner - Obstetrics/Gynecology (NY)
Accepts assignmentYes (participating)

Medicare services in 2024

Medicare patients30
Services billed56 across 13 procedure codes
Paid by Medicare$2,981

Part D prescriptions in 2024

Prescriptions (claims)177 · 407 30-day fills
Patients59
Total drug cost$36,810
Generic share74% of claims

Medicare sources and data years

Education and affiliations

Medical schoolLake Erie College of Osteopathic Medicine, Erie
Graduation year2015
Medicare specialtyObstetrics/Gynecology

Medical group

Source: CMS Care Compare

Industry payments (Open Payments)

  • 2025$106.57 · 6 payments from 5 companies
  • 2024$216.23 · 12 payments from 7 companies

Top paying companies in 2025

CompanyAmountPayments
Biogen, Inc.$37.672
Pfizer Inc.$22.681
Dexcom, Inc.$20.491
Amgen Inc.$17.041
Organon LLC$8.691

What the 2025 payments were for

  • Food and Beverage$106.57 · 6 payments

Receiving payments does not imply wrongdoing. What Open Payments covers ·original records

Other OB-GYNs in Buffalo

All 63 OB-GYNs in Buffalo · All OB-GYNs in New York